Urban Planning Doesn’t Exist

Urban Planning Doesn’t Exist

An Essay on Territorial Governance — Roberto Deriu

The urban plan does not decide; it is decided elsewhere. This is what I concluded.

In the press

“When Procedure Replaces Conscience”

An essay written for Cassandra Voices (Ireland), published on 8 October 2026. Anyone who has sat in a planning office learns the order in which the questions arise: is the application admissible, which subsection applies, how long do we have to reply. Whether what is authorised will do the place any good comes last. Read the essay.

“Cala Liberotto Was My Summer”

An essay written for Terrain.org (United States), published on 8 October 2026. A stretch of the Sardinian coast seen first as a child and then from the other side of the table: pines planted with public money, common land sold off, houses that arrive before the law. Read the essay.

Everything else that has appeared, the review and the exchange it started, is listed in Notes.

Urban Planning Doesn’t Exist — Roberto Deriu

Urban Planning Doesn’t Exist is an essay against the discipline its author practised from the inside.

In that time he adopted master plans, amended them, defended them and watched them annulled. This book sets out what he concluded: that planning is neither an autonomous science — it borrows its method from law and engineering — nor an effective power. The plan arrives after the bargain has been struck, and its function is to make the bargain lawful. Where it cannot, it is bypassed by derogation.

The argument is built in two registers. The first is historical: the essay follows the discipline’s own account of itself, from Vitruvius and Palladio through Howard’s garden city, Mumford, Jacobs, the Athens Charter, Venturi and Scott Brown, Koolhaas and Harvey, and shows how each generation restated a claim to a power the discipline never held. The second is documentary: fifteen years of Italian housing acts, amnesties and emergency measures, and a Constitutional Court that has struck them down four times while the buildings remained.

What follows is not resignation but a proposal. If negotiation is the real instrument of territorial governance, it should be named, taught in planning schools, disclosed in public and regulated by law — who was in the room, what was offered, what was obtained, and what is enforceable afterwards.

An appendix examines Sardinia, where the mechanism is easiest to see: primary legislative power over planning since 1948, a coastal plan that leaves half the island — the half that is depopulating — outside it, a building derogation extended for twelve years, and a landscape regime dismantled in the courts.

The record

  • Thirteen of fourteen landscape plans, annulled in the courts.
  • One coastal plan in force, covering a fraction of the shoreline.
  • Fifteen years of housing acts and amnesties, four of them struck down by the Constitutional Court.
  • The buildings are still there.

This is Sardinia, and it is not an Italian curiosity: it is what happens anywhere the plan is asked to do work that was actually done at a negotiating table.

The argument

  1. The plan ratifies, it does not decide.It arrives after the bargain has produced an outcome, and its function is to make that outcome lawful.
  2. Urban planning is not a science.It borrows its authority from law, its vocabulary from engineering, and its legitimacy from a promise of neutrality it cannot keep.
  3. Derogation is the regime.Fifteen years of housing acts, amnesties and emergency measures have made the exception the ordinary way of building; four rulings of the Constitutional Court have not changed what stands.
  4. If the instrument is negotiation, govern the negotiation.Principled negotiation: interests instead of positions, objective criteria agreed in advance, a written record of what was traded.
  5. Islands and coasts make the mechanism visible.Primary legislative power over planning since 1948, a coastal plan that leaves half the island — the half that is depopulating — outside it, a building derogation extended for twelve years, and a landscape regime dismantled in the courts.
“Urban planning does not exist. The territory, the interests, the people exist. And there exists — when we decide to exercise it — the politics that brings them to agreement.”From the preface

What is in the book

  1. Preface
  2. The Ancient Order: When the City Was Cosmology
  3. The City as Police, as Statistics, as Art
  4. The Corrective Utopia: Fleeing the Metropolis to Save It
  5. The Short Century of the Total Plan
  6. The Revolt of the Sidewalk
  7. The Contemporary Dissolution
  8. The Laws We Have, the Territory We Do Not Govern
  9. What Remains, If Urban Planning Does Not Exist. The Final Proposal
  10. Appendix. Endemic Laws: The Case of Sardinia
  11. Annotated Bibliography
  12. Index of Names

English edition, 2026. 133 pages.

Roberto Deriu

About the author

Roberto Deriu is an Italian journalist and writer. He writes on politics, power and negotiation. His personal site is robertoderiu.eu.

Keep in touch

When something new appears, I will say so.

Not more than once a month, and only when there is a new essay, a review, or a public argument about the book. An address is all that is needed.

You will receive one message asking you to confirm. You can leave whenever you like, with a single click.

Read the opening. The preface and the first chapter are free to read. If the argument is wrong, it should be possible to see that in twenty minutes.

Read the prefaceFor editors and researchers

© 2026 Roberto Deriu. Italian edition: L’urbanistica non esiste. Saggio sul governo del territorio.press@urbanplanningdoesntexist.com